Skip to Content

9 Best Banana Sheet Cake Recipes To Try Today

Do you want a new banana sheet cake recipe to try today? Maybe you want to try making a banana sheet cake but don’t know where to start?

Or are you curious about banana sheet cakes and want to know more? Whatever your reason is, we have the answers for you! 

9 Best Banana Sheet Cake Recipes To Try Today

Finding a banana sheet cake recipe can be tricky, especially if you have never made a sheet cake before.

You head online for some guidance but are met with page after page of conflicting and contradicting information.

Frustrated and overwhelmed, you are left unsure who to trust or where to turn. You wonder if you will ever find the best banana sheet cake recipe to try. 

Well, no more! Today, we are here with the answers you need. Keep reading to see the 9 best banana sheet cake recipes to try today.

Get ready to become a banana sheet cake expert and find the perfect recipe to wow your friends and family with. 

1. Banana Sheet Cake

First up, we have this wonderful recipe from Simply Recipes. The banana sheet cake is paired with a cream cheese frosting that is tangy and sweet, perfect for everyone to enjoy!

Plus, this cake is huge! The recipe can easily serve 30 people, making it perfect for pirates, tailgates, or a feast for your family to enjoy! 

The recipe is super easy to follow, with just seven steps that will allow you to create the perfect cake. Be sure to leave the butter and cream cheese out while you make your cake.

This way, they will have time to soften, making it easier for you to make your topping! Save your arms (and whisk) from the workout by softening them first. 

2. Banana Sheet Cake With Caramel Frosting

If you have a sweet tooth, this banana sheet cake with caramel frosting is perfect for you! The moist banana cake is paired with a caramel frosting that you are sure to love, it’s sweet and the use of brown sugar elevates it above other frostings!

The steps of the recipe are easy to follow and come with plenty of tips and tricks for you to follow. There are even tips on the best way to store your sheet cake to ensure that it lasts for days. 

Make sure that your frosting spreads easily before you add it to your cooled sheet cake. If the frosting is stiff, it will pull the top of the cake away as you spread it, leaving you with a mess!

Add a few drops of milk to make your frosting easier to spread before applying it to your cake for success. 

3. Simple Banana Sheet Cake

We love any recipe with simple in the title, and this one from Ashley Manila is the perfect easy banana sheet cake recipe to follow!

This banana sheet cake is perfectly moist and stays moist for days, you don’t need to worry about this cake going stale quickly! 

It is finished with a simple cream cheese frosting that you can customize to suit your tastes. We loved adding some chopped nuts, cinnamon, or chocolate chips to ours. Simply add your favorite toppings and you are good to go! 

The recipe calls for toasted pecans, but you can swap them for other nuts if you prefer. Walnuts or pistachios work well with bananas if you want to use up the nuts you have at home.

For those with nut allergies, swap out the nuts for some sliced bananas. It works just as well! 

4. Gluten-Free Banana Sheet Cake

If you need a gluten-free banana sheet cake, this is the recipe for you! Almond flour is used to make this recipe gluten-free, combined with cashew butter and coconut sugar to give the cake a unique taste.

You can also use gluten-free flour if you don’t have almonds to hand, simply swap out the almond flour for the same amount of gluten-free flour. 

Cashew butter adds a nutty flavor to the cake that you are sure to love. Make sure that the cashew butter is creamy style, rather than chunky as it will impact the final texture of the cake.

You can also swap it out for different nut butter, like almond if you prefer. 

The chocolate cream cheese frosting is beautiful and sets the cake apart from others on the list. Plus, it brings an extra sweetness to the cake that you are sure to love!

5. Vegan Banana Oatmeal Sheet Cake

For the vegans in the room, we have the perfect recipe for you! This banana oatmeal sheet cake works as a dessert, but is also the perfect breakfast or snack!

The cake is topped with a  wonderful maple buttercream that adds lots of sweetness and flavor to the cake. Plus, you can use the topping on other cakes if you wish, it works well with cinnamon rolls or sandwich cookies. 

The cake is spiced well thanks to the use of allspice, ginger, cinnamon, and nutmeg. You can adjust the spice quantities to suit your taste if you wish, but we think you will love how the spices complement the bananas! 

Top the frosting with some toasted pecans, or any nut of your choosing. For those with nut allergies, you can use chocolate chips or even sliced bananas.

You will also want to swap the almond milk for oat or soy. 

6. Banana Sheet Cake With Brown Butter Frosting

That’s right, we have another easy recipe for you to follow! This banana sheet cake is topped with a brown butter cream cheese buttercream that you are sure to love.

It is packed full of flavor and sweetness, with the added taste of ripe bananas! 

For best results, make sure your bananas are ripe as they will deliver the most sweetness and taste to the cake. Ideally, the bananas should have black spots on their skin and be easy to mash. 

This is a quick recipe, taking just 30 minutes! It’s perfect when you don’t have much time and need to make a large cake that will please everyone!

Be sure to follow the steps and tips provided in the recipe for a wonderful banana sheet cake. 

7. Best Banana Sheet Cake

We are always dubious of any recipe that claims to be the best, but this banana sheet cake one is fantastic! Not only is the cake moist, but it doesn’t fall apart when you bite into it! There are no sweeping-up crumbs with this recipe!

It does take longer to cook than other recipes on the list, and it only serves 12, but it is worth it! The banana flavor is complemented beautifully by cinnamon, brown sugar, and a delicious cream cheese frosting. 

The recipe itself is easy to follow and comes with plenty of tips and tricks to make the baking process as smooth as possible. Plus, there are hints on how to turn this sheet cake into cupcakes, bundt cakes, and even a layer cake! 

8. Easy Banana Sheet Cake

That’s right, we have another easy banana sheet cake recipe for you! This recipe allows you to make a tender and moist cake that is topped with a stunning cream cheese frosting.

You don’t need many ingredients for this recipe either, making it perfect for using up items in your pantry. ‘You don’t need many ingredients for this recipe either, making it perfect for using up items in your pantry. 

While the recipe calls for whole milk, you can also use low-fat milk, or dairy-free milk if you prefer. The recipe is easy to follow and features pictures with every step, so you can see what your cake should look like every step of the way. 

There are also helpful tips and hints that make the baking process even easier. What’s more, Should you make a mistake, the recipe has lots of tips that will allow you to fix them with ease. 

9. Sheet Pan Banana Cake Healthy

Finally, we have this wonderful recipe that shows you how to make a healthy banana sheet cake. In just eight steps, you can have a tasty banana sheet cake that is spiced beautifully and finished with some mini chocolate chips! 

Half of the chips are added to the mixture, allowing them to melt as the cake bakes, and the other half is added to the top.

You could also add a topping of your own choice if you wish, why not try your favorite healthy frosting or caramel topping? You can also serve the cake as it is, it still tastes great! 

Final Thoughts

And there you have it, the 9 best banana sheet cake recipes to try today! Whether you want a healthy banana sheet cake or a gluten-free, vegan, or easy-to-follow recipe, you are sure to find what you are looking for today!

Make sure to use all of the tips and tricks we provided within the article and follow the recipes to ensure your banana sheet cake is perfect every time you make it! Happy baking!

Anna Ingham
Latest posts by Anna Ingham (see all)

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Brett Daniels says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview; your comment will be visible after it has been approved.
    All the latest gaming information, recreation critiques and trailers A one-stop store for all things video games.Spider-Man No Way Home full movie
  2. undress vip says:
    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview; your comment will be visible after it has been approved.
    Thanks so much for the blog post.Much thanks again. Fantastic.